Summary:
- Tom Bruch, John Saye
- Soft scaffolds, the dynamic actions of a teacher or peer in support of an activity
- Hard scaffolds: the static supports that can be planned in advance.
- Four types of scaffolding (Hannafin, Land, Oliver, 1999)
- Conceptual:
- "here's the help you'll need for understanding this concept
- --> highlight important concepts, provide questions or definition
- Strategic:
- --> bullet points/ listing / diagrams
- Metacognitive
- --> reflection
- Procedural
- --> clip guy-information on procedure
- Things to think about:
- Complexity: ease vs challenge
- Structure: contrived vs realistic/ authentic
- Depth: basic vs deep understanding
- Decision points
- Presentation of content
- Practice
- Feedback
- Assessment
- Feedback
- Conclusion(reflection)
- A word about fading
- The goal: fade the support; achieve learner independence
- We don't always get this right
- How do we consider scaffolding in our design?
- Intentional design decisions
- Hard scaffolding
- Soft scaffolding
- With consideration for
- Complexity
- Structure
- depth
- At various decision points
- Presentation
- Practice/feedback
- Assessment/feedback
- What's the difference between a job aid and a scaffold?
- Technology tools for job aids/ scaffolding
- Adobe captivate
- Groups diigo
Reflection:
"What's the difference
between a job aid and a scaffold? "
To answer this question, I searched for
more information on job aids and I found these two links to be extremely
helpful: Designing
a job aid, Dave's Ensampler. Based
on my understanding, they are different in the following aspects:
Job Aids
|
Scaffold
|
|
Purpose
|
To quickly access
information to perform a task
|
To effectively
acquire knowledge during task execution
|
Design
|
Gear towards one
specific task
|
Gear towards
specific learning goals
|
Element
|
Only involves
presentation
|
Involves
presentation, practice, feedback and assessment
|
Type
|
Tend to be
procedural
|
Can be conceptual,
strategic, metacognitive or procedural.
|
Basically, I feel
that job aid is a part of scaffolding process while scaffolding involves a
broader scope of learner's learning. I don't know if I understand correctly though...
I like your breakdown of the differences at the end of your post. I think the two that stand out most to me are purpose and element. I also agree that I think job aids are part of scaffolding, and part of overall understanding of one's job through the detailed breakdown of one aspect of it.
ReplyDeleteI think I am in agreement with your understanding of what a job aid and what scaffolding is, overall. I do think, though, that some job aids can address the issue of feedback by whether or not the final result you have before you matches the final result the job aid has dictated you should reach.